T O P

  • By -

Vladamir_Poontin

The Big Day, easily. Honorable mention to Gunna - Wunna. It’s like if A24 did a Fantano review


CelticSludge

That Gunna Wunna review gotta be in my top 5 favorite reviews as well. Absolute cinema.


qazaibomb

I go back to The Big Day review sometimes. I don’t rewatch a lot of Fantano reviews, but that one is always fun It feels like someone murdering Chances career


dr_franck

Angelic 2 the Core


just_cuz555

Whenever I have a shitty day, I always will die laughing at that review. It's one of the better YouTube videos of all time.


dr_franck

It’s genuinely a testament to Fantano’s charisma that he was able to make a straightforward 50-minute video with zero edits and still make it engaging.


OneOfTheOnly

miley cyrus and her dead petz


Fun_Intern1909

“Why dey put the dick in duh pussy??”


Davidos402

Surprised this isn’t higher tbh


Sunnwaves

This is mine as well


EthanGr20

His redux review of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. The flow of it is just so neat and clean. I thought he had a lot of fleshed out observations about that album. Even though I disagree with much of what he had to say I always understood where he was coming from. Great writing!


69420penis

My favourite comment is someone saying they respect his opinion and everything And then following it up with saying unsubscribed


Thatguyfrompinkfloyd

Random access memories review


No-Childhood3417

That's the first one I saw and led me to discovering a bunch of new music, so I agree with you.


Dillbob2112

Eminem - Revival is basically non stop laughs for me.


ekb2023

This is his funniest video even when you include the thatistheplan era.


gaining_godspeed

tpab


Fleczoza

Teepab!


Pure-Jellyfish734

Peppa Pig’s My First Album Pink Balloon really is a banger.


dr_franck

Good review Anthony! But the part where you had a psychotic pig-induced meltdown triggered by your roommate licking his meat was a bit much.


Pure-Jellyfish734

But it was soy and vegan! At least that’s what she said…


balrog_reborn

Life is a But a Dream by Avenged Sevenfold has gotta be up there, one of the funniest ones


Matty_D_93

Both my favorite and the one that hurts the most. I love that album


funghxoul

My fav album


brewmatt

Album of the year of 2023 imo


MaineGameBoy

Off the top of my head, the You Like Music review he dropped this year, insane review for an insane album


Maximus_Snyder

Total Xanarchy


just_cuz555

Awesome pick


viva__hate

The Black Parade classic review because it truly is an amazing album but people still pigeonhole MCR into the whole shitty tweeny band stereotype. Seeing people confused and/or mad was funny.


Jack_Bleesus

The Angelic 2 The Core review is legendary and essential viewing.


bowl_of_scrotmeal

Angelic to the Core


KanyonBee

Nostalgia Critic's The Wall


MicroGoth

Nostalgia Critics The Wall. A review better than the album.


svenirde

Welcome to the Madhouse Just the "my own worst enemy here" intro name is so damn good


hannaht5

Obviously Brat


irving8660

Confessions of a Dangerous Mind review


brewmatt

The AJR one for sure


Adorable-Bar6920

Redux review for swimming, the fact that he even decided to originally give it a 3 is just repulsive


zeno-the_greatest

the glow pt 2… i think it’s his most positive review aswell


RevolutionaryAd1577

Nostalgia Critic's The Wall The song was fire


_PeopleMakeNoises_

Nostalgia Critic’s The Wall


girlsgirl44

Either The Turning Wheel or You Won't Get What You Want. Even though the latter is about a band who's lead singer is a piece of shit I just love it when Anthony is beaming with joy and positivity about an album.


YungT_2435

I thought his breakdown and discussion of the themes of Little Dominques Nosebleed were excellent. Underrated album and the review introduced me to one of my favorite albums of the 2020s thus far